V-brake calipers

[Canardweb]

So, as V-brake adapters and pads are now back on the market, it's time to change these HS33 brakes for something better. Here is the setup I aim for:

Levers: Avid SD7

Pads: Heatsink (if they make some) or TNN

Outer and inner cable: Shimano SP51 or Odyssey Linear Slick along with Clarks or any pre-stretched teflon covered cable.

Adapters: Heatsink or Tarty ones depending on how they look.

I am now in need of calipers. I don't know if they really make a difference performance wise so what should I get? Avid Ultimate or Shimano XTR are overpriced but maybe they are the best? Otherwise what other option do I have that suit trials use?

I have always used basic Shimano ones in the past but now I really want to know if something is best?

Thanks for the advices and your time!

 

[aener]

I just use SD5s with an FR5 lever. Can't fault them. Work amazingly and cheap as chips. I really don't think it's worth spending any more money than that.
The key is to use SP51, as you mentioned.

I got the TNN pads and they're fine. Nothing lifechanging. They're just pads. They reliably stop the wheel.

 

SD7 vs FR5 levers: SD7 has the adjustment and so can deliver more power, but I find it makes the brake feel spongier.
This is the same when using them with a disc. I currently have an SD7 on the vee because I snapped my FR5 and that's what I had spare, but the FR5 feels stiffer under the finger, and works better as a result.
The FR5 is also simpler with just the one moving part, and a fixed anchor. Feels nicer in terms of response, same lever blade shape for ultimate comfort, marginally lighter, cheaper... can't really beat that!

[Canardweb]

29 minutes ago, aener said:

I just use SD5s with an FR5 lever. Can't fault them. Work amazingly and cheap as chips. I really don't think it's worth spending any more money than that.
The key is to use SP51, as you mentioned.

I got the TNN pads and they're fine. Nothing lifechanging. They're just pads. They reliably stop the wheel.

 

SD7 vs FR5 levers: SD7 has the adjustment and so can deliver more power, but I find it makes the brake feel spongier.
This is the same when using them with a disc. I currently have an SD7 on the vee because I snapped my FR5 and that's what I had spare, but the FR5 feels stiffer under the finger, and works better as a result.
The FR5 is also simpler with just the one moving part, and a fixed anchor. Feels nicer in terms of response, same lever blade shape for ultimate comfort, marginally lighter, cheaper... can't really beat that!

That's really interesting. Thanks for your input. I really wanted to go with SD7 levers but well, you made me think...

There has been so much experiencing by Atomz when they were made by Sunn with V-brakes it's crazy. That led to the ATS system the Jealousy still uses actually. So many factors can change the feel of the lever or the behaviour of the brake it's almost impossible to make the brake perfect for everyone. As you say the adjustment on the SD7 makes the brake spongier but it should also make it more more powerful. So it's always a compromise you have to choose. Some top riders like Robin Berchiatti for example prefer a spongier brake feeling with Hope brakes, others with HS33 and I don't know why. It's always down to personal preference I guess!