ive had both.
My try-alls went exactly the same as yours, ive had severa pairs and theyve all gone like that. I even had them re-soled and they went again.
My ribos. The soles are still ok think there is a tiny hole beggining to show. However the material has torn this happened within a month of me getting them, i have holes near the ankles now. It has improved ventilation :blink: but no not happy. Im not too keen on the monty ones but might give them a go.