Good point, hadn't thought of that However, if Mr X is better qualified than Mr Y to do Mr Y's job, then why not put Mr X in his place and let Mr Y take the lower job? Or Mr Y can train himself up to keep his current job. Possibly a little 'cynical' though... Maybe I'm just a big capitalist at heart, haha? I certainly think people who work hard to get where they are tend to harbour their beliefs on that 'side of the fence' anyway.